Indian cinema is a global powerhouse, yet a concerning trend has become an industry standard: the normalization of aggression as a primary communication tool. From dramatic workplace showdowns to high-decibel family squabbles, movies often depict yelling and threats as the only way to establish authority. This suggests a false reality where "heroism" is tied to being the loudest person in the room.
In truth, Indian culture is historically rooted in patience, community cohesion, and nuanced hierarchy. On-screen aggression creates a distorted feedback loop, leading audiences to believe that professional or familial respect is only valid if it is backed by a threat.
The Distortion of the Professional and Personal
- The Workplace: Films often glorify the "aggressive boss" archetype. This undermines modern organizational shifts toward emotional intelligence and psychological safety, which research shows are critical for long-term productivity and innovation.
- The Family Unit: Using shouting as a plot device for "tough love" validates toxic behaviors in real households. It creates an environment where boundaries are enforced through fear rather than understanding.
True influence stems from clarity and empathy. Fortunately, a growing wave of modern cinema is rejecting these tropes. Films like The Great Indian Kitchen, Piku, and Kapoor & Sons demonstrate that impact comes from silence and conversation rather than external theatrics.
The Call to Action: Voting with Your Attention
Cinema is a commercial industry that responds to demand. If we want to see our cultural values of respect and restraint reflected accurately, we must change how we consume entertainment. Here is how we can reward films that uphold these standards:
- Selective Consumption: Prioritize "word-of-mouth" films that celebrate emotional maturity. When we buy tickets for movies that substitute noise for depth, we signal to producers that aggression sells.
- The Power of the Review: Use social platforms and review sites to specifically highlight healthy conflict resolution. When a film handles a workplace or family disagreement with dignity, call it out as a strength.
- Supporting Independent Voices: Smaller regional films often lead the way in realistic storytelling. Supporting these creators helps shift the industry's center of gravity away from "angry hero" formulas.
- Discuss the "Why" with Family: When a movie shows a character hitting or yelling to get their way, use it as a teaching moment. Discussing why that behavior is a failure of character rather than a sign of strength helps break the normalization cycle for the next generation.
By consciously choosing to reward narratives that value dialogue over dominance, we can ensure that the mirror cinema holds up to our society reflects the best of who we are, not the loudest.
Comments